Wednesday, December 28, 2011

Eggnog Soaked French Toast Casserole

I always knew I wanted Christmas Morning Breakfast to be a really big deal in my house. You know, once The Husband and I started a family and painfully began melding our individual traditions into a smorgasbord of our own sweet M Family traditions. Thankfully, this was one tradition we could easily agree on! 

Among the many delicious dishes that flooded our table Christmas morning, I would venture to guess that the Eggnog Soaked French Toast Casserole was the family favorite all around. It's a really simple and sinfully delicious recipe that I adapted from Paula Deen's Baked French Toast Casserole.

Feeds 6 with leftovers. Don't forget you'll want to make this casserole the night before and refrigerate it overnight. 

What You'll Need:

- 3 loaves of Pepperidge Farm Swirl Bread. You can substitute French or Challah bread for this recipe although for Christmas morning, I chose to spice and sweeten things up a bit with the swirl breads. I went with 2 loaves of Raisin Cinnamon Swirl and 1 loaf of Cinnamon and Brown Sugar Swirl. 
- 9 large eggs
- 1 1/2c half and half
- 1/2c eggnog. You can substitute an additional 1/2c of eggnog for the 1/2c half and half mentioned above. I was afraid it would be overwhelmingly noggy but it wasn't! I will certainly add more eggnog next time!
- 1c whole milk
- 2 shakes vanilla
- 1 tablespoon granulated sugar
- 1 tablespoon light brown sugar and additional brown sugar to crumble over the top of the casserole prior to cooking
- 3 shakes ground cinnamon
- 3 shakes ground nutmeg
- Dash of salt
- Maple syrup for serving
- Whipped cream for serving

What You'll Do!:

1. Generously butter your 9x13 casserole dish
2. Cut or tear your slices of bread into halves. Assemble and layer them in the casserole dish in 2-3 layers. I used a slightly larger casserole dish and ended up with 2 layers and then a small 3rd layer in the center. Be sure to overlap the slices.
3. In a medium mixing bowl, combine all ingredients except maple syrup, whipped cream and extra brown sugar and blend thoroughly. You do not need a hand mixer for this- I just used a large whisk. Do not over whisk.
4. Pour mixture over bread slices and be sure to evenly coat every slice. Spoon mixture between slices if you need you. use the back of a spoon to press down on the slices to ensure maximum delicious coverage. 
5. Cover with foil and refrigerate overnight. 

The next morning: 

1. Preheat oven to 350*
2. Sprinkle light brown sugar over the top of your casserole.
3. Bake for 40 minutes or until puffy and light golden brown.
4. Top with whipped cream, maple syrup and serve! 



  1. Oh good God I think I gained 5 lbs just reading this! Sounds so damn good! Better than my breakfast crockpot casserole for sure!

  2. definitely want to try this! Sounds so good!

  3. Mmmmmm...that sounds delish!! :)
    I will def. be trying this!

  4. Wow, wow and wow. That looks amazing! Hope you guys had a great christmas!

  5. That looks amazing! Thanks for the recipe. Can't wait to try it!

  6. I love anything soaked in eggnog.

  7. printing a copy now, going to grocery store late and trying for tomorrow morning!!! mmm mmmm!!!! :) i LOVE eggnog!

  8. So perfect because our tradition is trying a different variation of french toast every year! We will definitely have to try this one--sounds delish!

  9. I just wrote this recipe down because I want to try it ASAP! It looks amazing! And I think I will splurge too and do the extra nogg! :) thanks love!

  10. I want this NOW. Sounds SO awesome!

  11. YUM! That looks delicious hun!! Thanks for sharing! :)


Thank you for reading ILYMTC. If you have any questions about a post or want to get in touch with me (or any of the cast of characters here at ILYMTC) email me at iloveyoumorethancarrots(at)gmail(dot)com.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...